Tag: eric cartman

traitor-boyfriend:

i am curious as to why kyle is so often seen as disingenuous when it comes to his beliefs. yes he can be hypocritical and a know-it-all and self-righteous but no one is putting it in his ear to think the way that he does; kyle is usually very sincere in how he thinks and more often than not he is on the right side of things. kyle is sympathetic and kind and genuinely wants to see good in people and there’s so much context to support that. i think where his egotism comes from in expressing his thoughts is a result of cartman constantly challenging and manipulating people against him has made kyle someone who feels he isn’t allowed to be wrong, which only exacerbates his stubborness and makes it harder for him to admit when he’s wrong or taken things to a dangerous extreme. kyle is and tries to be a good person who just sometimes gets too into his own head

After last season, where Kyle caused millions of people to die, can we stop acting as if he’s so much better and more “moral” than Cartman though?

traitor-boyfriend:

this is inherently going to sound like i’m being defensive of kyle – which, i am, but i don’t know how to explain to you if it’s not readily apparent that there’s a big difference between kyle speaking recklessly in anger to an inopportune person that inadvertently and indirectly results in innocent peoples’ deaths – of which he is wrecked w guilt about afterward b/c he had no intention or desire to have done so – and cartman routinely psychologically breaking people in malice and either attempting to or successfully orchestrating their physical harm and/or deaths for personal satisfaction which he has almost never felt anything resembling regret or remorse for

THIS^

I wrote about this one time, but I have yet to see every season, so idk how the whole Heidi thing also screwed with Kyle’s emotions. Watching the episode tho the impression I got was that:

It seems Kyle felt that part of Canada’s culture and its worldview of such ‘mean’ things is what has made people be so ruthless and mean with one another, hence wanting people to be aware of this and stop it so maybe the world can start to be more kinder. I mean, idk, if within the show’s universe Canada’s culture is like that or that’s just how they view humor, regardless if its on tv or not. Canada’s tv show of Terrance and Philip basically potrayed this – that people don’t care about the misfortune of others, hence laughing at people being farted on. So, maybe this is a cultural problem. And maybe that’s how Kyle viewd it hence the strike against Canada itself. But of course people can he so hostle and downright stupid when it comes to politics and controversial views, so no surprise it went horribly wrong.

But like you said, at least Kyle was shocked and repented by the missile attack on Canada. He NEVER meant for it to go that far. His emotions got the better of him and definitley influenced his lack of carefulness with his words and the possible reprucussions that his actions would bring.

Again, I haven’t seen all of South Park nor all of the events leading up to the missile strike, but that’s just the impression I got. Just wanted to add my two cents in. Maybe I’m wrong on what Kyle felt, but I do know for a fact that Kyle would not have wanted the death of millions of Canadians. At most maybe he just wanted to cancel the series.